Banks are on pace this year to merge at a level not seen since the 2008 financial crisis. It is a sharp turnaround from last year, when the economy spiraled and many regional and community banks put merger plans on the shelf. Now, bank executives are feeling more certain about what the future holds, but some are finding it hard to make it on their own. Though the economy has in many ways recovered from 2020, loan demand is still low and profits from lending are slim.
Banks have announced more than $54 billion in deals through late September, according to Dealogic. That puts industry mergers and acquisitions on pace for their biggest year since 2008, when some big banks had to sell themselves to stave off collapse. At this time last year, banks had announced just $17 billion in mergers.
Banks typically spend weeks or months turning a potential target’s loan book upside down, searching for risky loans or other red flags, before agreeing to acquire it. But the Covid-19 pandemic muddied that process. For months, lenders struggled to assess the creditworthiness of their own customers, much less those of their competitors.
“Neither potential sellers nor buyers really wanted to do a transaction last year because of the uncertainty that could be on folks’ balance sheets,” said Kevin Riley, chief executive of First Interstate BancSystem Inc. FIBK -0.17% in Billings, Mont.
But the expected wave of loan defaults never materialized, and by the end of last year, serious merger conversations resumed, according to executives and regulatory filings. This month, First Interstate FIBK -0.17% agreed to buy regional lender Great Western Bancorp Inc. in a deal that will boost its assets to more than $32 billion.
“[Banks] are no longer fearful of the bottom falling out,” said Nathan Stovall, an analyst at S&P Global Market Intelligence. “They are no longer looking at a deal like trying to catch a falling knife.”2019 was also a big year for bank mergers, but more of the major regionals are in play this year. So while there are fewer deals this year than at this point in 2019, the overall value is higher than it was two years ago.
Minneapolis-based U.S. Bancorp last week said it plans to buy MUFG Union Bank’s core retail-banking operations, boosting its presence on the West Coast. Another major regional, Citizens Financial Group Inc., said in July that it plans to buy Investors Bancorp Inc. Investors Bank had shelved merger talks with another bank when the pandemic hit in 2020, according to regulatory filings.
The Federal Reserve cut interest rates to near zero when the pandemic hit, and low rates have made it more difficult for banks to profit from their bread-and-butter business of lending. The average net interest margin, a measure of lending profitability, reached a record low of 2.5% in the second quarter, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.
Smaller banks have also struggled to compete with the high-end digital offerings and technology of the megabanks.
Sacramento, Calif.-based Bank of Commerce Holdings began courting potential merger partners in the spring of 2021. The board and management of the $1.9-billion-assets bank had for years considered different options to overcome ever-narrowing industry margins, including being acquired by a larger bank, CEO Randy Eslick said. It took less than three months to iron out a deal with $18 billion Columbia Banking System Inc. of Tacoma, Wash.
The deal was announced in June, and the combined bank will have the resources to invest in technology and other areas—trust departments, wealth management, specialty lending—that the smaller Bank of Commerce wouldn’t have been able to fund on its own.
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
What impact will the boom in bank mergers have on customers? Join the conversation below.
“Those types of things bring technology to the table that we could not afford to,” Mr. Eslick said. “At the end of the day, we have more arrows in our quiver.”
The pressure to scale up has only grown more intense in recent years, said Scott Wylie, CEO of the $2 billion First Western Financial Inc. in Denver. In July, First Western said it would buy the parent company of a smaller bank, the nearby Rocky Mountain Bank.
“For a $300- or $500- or $700-million bank, it used to be you could have a nice little business that could go for a long time,” Mr. Wylie said. “These days, that’s really hard.” Conway, Ark.-based Home BancShares Inc. said this month it would buy Happy Bancshares for more than $900 million. Within weeks, CEO John Allison got pitched another deal.
“Someone said to me, ‘Johnny, the body hasn’t even gotten cold yet…and they’re bringing all these other deals,’” Mr. Allison said.
By: Orla McCaffrey at email@example.com
- Stemler, Gregory; Welch, Shea; Johnson, Jeff; Mims, John; Davison, Brian. “Methods for Developing a Rigorous Pre-Deal M&A Strategy”. Transaction Advisors. ISSN 2329-9134. (Subscription required.)
- Investment banking explained pp. 223-224
- Harwood, 2005
- The Economist, ‘The new rules of attraction’, 15 Nov 2014
- Rumyantseva, Maria, Grzegorz Gurgul, and Ellen Enkel. “Knowledge Integration after Mergers & Acquisitions.” University of Mississippi Business Department. University of Mississippi, July 2002.
- Ranft, Annette L., and Michael D. Lord. “Acquiring new technologies and capabilities: A grounded model of acquisition implementation.” Organization science 13.4 (2002): 420-441.
- Moore, Jim (2012-12-26). “Get acquired! An idiot’s guide to technology M&A”. Retrieved 19 August 2013.
- “Mergers & Acquisitions Quick Reference Guide” (PDF). McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP. Retrieved 19 August 2013.
- Griffin, William F. “Tax Aspects of Corporate Mergers and Acquisitions” (PDF). Davis Malm & D’Agostine, P.C. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 May 2013. Retrieved 19 August 2013.
- Barusch, Ronald (2010-11-09). “WSJ M&A 101: A Guide to Merger Agreements”. WSJ Deal Journal. Retrieved 19 August 2013.
- “How to Value a Business – SMERGERS”. SMERGERS.
- W. Brotherson, K. Eades, R. Harris, R. Higgins (2014). Company Valuation in Mergers and Acquisitions: How is Discounted Cash Flow Applied by Leading Practitioners?, Journal of Applied Finance, Vol. 24;2.
- Collan, Mikael; Kinnunen Jani (2011). “A Procedure for the Rapid Pre-acquisition Screening of Target Companies Using the Pay-off Method for Real Option Valuation”. Journal of Real Options and Strategy. 4 (1): 117–141. doi:10.12949/realopn.4.117.
- King, D. R.; Slotegraaf, R.; Kesner, I. (2008). “Performance implications of firm resource interactions in the acquisition of R&D-intensive firms”. Organization Science. 19 (2): 327–340. doi:10.1287/orsc.1070.0313.
- Maddigan, Ruth; Zaima, Janis (1985). “The Profitability of Vertical Integration”. Managerial and Decision Economics. 6 (3): 178–179. doi:10.1002/mde.4090060310.
- Ng, Artie W.; Chatzkel, Jay; Lau, K.F.; Macbeth, Douglas (2012-07-20). “Dynamics of Chinese emerging multinationals in cross‐border mergers and acquisitions”. Journal of Intellectual Capital. 13 (3): 416–438. doi:10.1108/14691931211248963. ISSN 1469-1930.
- Zhang, Yu; Wu, Xianming; Zhang, Hao; Lyu, Chan; Zhang, Yu; Wu, Xianming; Zhang, Hao; Lyu, Chan (2018-05-30). “Cross-Border M&A and the Acquirers’ Innovation Performance: An Empirical Study in China”. Sustainability. 10 (6): 1796. doi:10.3390/su10061796.
- Cunningham, Colleen; Ederer, Florian; Ma, Song (2018). “Killer Acquisitions”. SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:10.2139/ssrn.3241707. ISSN 1556-5068. S2CID 219391535.
- Hollenbeck, Brett (2020). “Horizontal Mergers and Innovation in Concentrated Industries” (PDF). Quantitative Marketing and Economics. 18: 1-37. doi:10.1007/S11129-019-09218-2. S2CID 219125831.
- King, D. R.; Dalton, D. R.; Daily, C. M.; Covin, J. G. (2004). “Meta-analyses of Post-acquisition Performance: Indications of Unidentified Moderators”. Strategic Management Journal. 25 (2): 187–200. doi:10.1002/smj.371.
- Amihud, Yakov; Baruch, Lev (1981). “Risk Reduction as a Managerial Motive for Conglomerate Mergers”. The Bell Journal of Economics. 12 (2): 605. doi:10.2307/3003575. JSTOR 3003575.
- Roll, Richard (1986). “The Hubris Hypothesis of Corporate Takeovers”. The Journal of Business. 59 (2): 197–216. doi:10.1086/296325. JSTOR 2353017.
- Malmendier, Ulrike; Tate, Geoffrey (2008). “Who makes acquisitions? CEO overconfidence and the market’s reaction”. Journal of Financial Economics. 89 (1). doi:10.1016/j.jfineco.2007.07.002. S2CID 12354773.
- “RECOMMENDED CASH OFFER FOR EIDOS PLC BY SQEX LTD. TO BE EFFECTED BY MEANS OF A SCHEME OF ARRANGEMENT UNDER THE UK COMPANIES ACT 2006” (PDF). Square Enix. 12 February 2009. Retrieved 16 February 2018.
- “From Software acquired by Japanese publisher Kadokawa Corporation”. Engadget. Retrieved 2017-12-10.
- “Notice Concerning Exchange of Shares to Convert Sammy NetWorks Co., Ltd., SEGA TOYS CO., LTD. and TMS ENTERTAINMENT, LTD. into Wholly Owned Subsidiaries of SEGA SAMMY HOLDINGS INC” (PDF). Sega Sammy Holdings Inc. 27 August 2010. Retrieved 9 January 2017.
- “MERGER & CONSOLIDATION: OVERVIEW”. http://www.shsu.edu. Retrieved 2017-12-10.
- In re Cox Communications, Inc. Shareholders Litig., 879 A.2d 604, 606 (Del. Ch. 2005).
- Hof, Robert. “Attention Startups: Here’s How To Get Acqui-Hired By Google, Yahoo Or Twitter”. Forbes. Retrieved 9 January 2014.
- Sarah E. Needleman (September 12, 2012). “Start-Ups Get Snapped Up for Their Talent”. Wall Street Journal.
- “M&A by Transaction Type – IMAA-Institute”. IMAA-Institute. Retrieved 2016-12-22.
- “NewsBeast And Other Merger Name Options « Merriam Associates, Inc. Brand Strategies”. Merriamassociates.com. Archived from the original on 2012-11-06. Retrieved 2012-12-18. “Caterpillar’s New Legs—Acquiring the Bucyrus International Brand « Merriam Associates, Inc. Brand Strategies”. Merriamassociates.com. Archived from the original on 2012-10-30. Retrieved 2012-12-18.