Loneliness Is a Public Health Problem: This Low-Tech Intervention Can Help

Loneliness is not just a feeling; it is also a public health problem that has been linked to increased risk of mental health issues, heart disease and even death. With rates of loneliness on the rise in the U. S. and around the world, people are addressing this crisis using everything from companion robots to social networking sites and apps. A new study in JAMA Psychiatry suggests that a better solution may lie in a much older, more ubiquitous form of technology: phone calls.

Even before the COVID-19 pandemic forced people into isolation, separating them from friends, co-workers and loved ones, experts were beginning to consider loneliness an epidemic—one affecting an estimated three out of five Americans. A study from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM), published last year, recognizes the health risks social isolation and loneliness present—and the limited interventions available to address them.

“There is a lot of variability in terms of the types of interventions, the level of evidence to support them and the rigor of evidence,” says Julianne Holt-Lunstad, a professor of psychology and neuroscience at Brigham Young University, who was a member of the NASEM committee that published the report.

Some potential solutions, such as grassroots-based pen-pal programs for socially isolated adults, sound promising based on anecdotal evidence, but researchers have not adequately studied them. Other experiments are still ongoing: Holt-Lunstad, in collaboration with the social-networking service Nextdoor and researchers in the U.K. and Australia, conducted a study (currently being prepared for publication) that suggests that performing small acts of kindness for neighbors reduced the likelihood of feeling lonely and socially isolated.

Now a new paper published in JAMA Psychiatry shows that a program of phone calls focused on empathetic conversation can help. Over the course of four weeks, the experiment saw an overall reduction in symptoms of loneliness, depression and anxiety in at-risk adults aged 27 to 101. “It makes sense,” says Linda Fried, dean of the Mailman School of Public Health at Columbia University, who was not involved in the study. “In an emergency time like the pandemic, phone calls can make a big difference in allaying feelings of fright and anxiety.”

“A lot of care went into designing the protocol so that it was all about the person at the other end,” says Maninder Kahlon, lead author of the study and executive director of Factor Health, an organization for developing health care programs at the University of Texas at Austin. For example, the experiment customized each person’s program depending on how frequently they wanted to receive calls—from two to five times per week—and the best time of day for them to talk.

The researchers also considered how to make the phone conversations more empathetic. Steven Tomlinson, co-author of the study and an associate professor of leadership and administration at Seminary of the Southwest in Austin, Tex., drew on his experiences reviewing successful sales calls to identify which variables could be applied to the intervention to help callers connect with other people.

These characteristics included asking open questions, making one point at a time to allow the call receiver to talk and following up on “clues” in the conversation to demonstrate understanding. Instead of writing a script, the researchers trained 16 callers, aged 17 to 23, in these techniques and instructed them to discuss any topic the call receiver wanted to talk about, such as an ongoing home-improvement project. “It’s not just calling up on people to check in,” Kahlon says. “It’s the deliberate thinking about how you build trust.”

Although it remains unclear if the effects last beyond the four-week study period, the researchers hope the study serves as a model for an ongoing program. If health care systems and public health agencies start building a workforce of empathetic callers, it could do more than alleviate loneliness, Kahlon suggests. Similar programs might help people with mild to moderate symptoms of depression and anxiety and complement patients’ management of chronic diseases such as diabetes and heart disease.

A phone-based intervention involving layperson callers would be accessible and scalable, but it would still require callers to undergo training and take on a lot of work. “It’s important that [the intervention] is simple and intuitive,” Kahlon says, but “simple does not mean easy.” Holt-Lunstad, who was not involved in the new study, also points out that loneliness has different sources and thus may need varying solutions. “One approach may not be appropriate for all, particularly if it’s not sensitive to the underlying causes,” Holt-Lunstad says. “Getting a phone call may work for one person, but participating in a group activity may be better for others.”

COVID has emphasized the need to address growing feelings of loneliness and isolation. For instance, Japan recently appointed a minister of loneliness in the wake of increasing rates of suicide in the country; the U.K. created a similar official position in 2018. “It may take some time to understand the long-term effects of the pandemic [on loneliness and social isolation],” Holt-Lunstad says. “One of the key takeaways from this past year is there is greater awareness of how important social connection is for our well-being.”

By Kasra Zarei

Source: Loneliness Is a Public Health Problem: This Low-Tech Intervention Can Help – Scientific American

.

.

How social workers can identify coercive and controlling behaviour
[…] for practice educators Managing fear in social work Fear and social work: podcast and transcript Loneliness and isolation during the pandemic: podcast and transcript Not sure if you have a licence? A larg […]
0
The people’s ambassadress: the forgotten diplomacy of Ivy Litvinov | Aeon Essays
aeon.co – Today
[…] Ivy’s private papers reveal the profound loneliness she felt once flung into this unexpected Soviet life of hers […] In returning to the Soviet Union, she was returning to a certain loneliness she’d known for decades as an oddly positioned Soviet outsider living in the Kremlin’s shadow […]
N/A
Europe’s most vulnerable have fallen through gaps in healthcare systems during the COVID pandemic | Euronews
[…] Europe caused an increase in social vulnerability, a drop in well-being, a rise in the feeling of loneliness, and mental health challenges, she added […]
N/A
Safeguarding Importance In An Ever-growing Online Education World
blog.edclass.com – Today
[…] produced by Children’s Commissioner for Wales Professor Sally Holland stated that: Isolation and loneliness will lead young children to become involved in dangerous predicaments as their intrigue is raised […]
0
Ambitious Youth Network
[…] The Ambitious Youth Network is part of a project to reduce loneliness in autistic young people by connecting them to others with shared interests […]
3
Think tank sheds light on why leaders struggle to invest in mental health
[…] Organisation, CIPD and other international research reveals that employee depression, anxiety and loneliness have soared during the pandemic, as reported […]
0
GrannyTech: 5 promising European startups keeping our grandparents busy
[…] One of the most pressing issues for seniors is isolation and loneliness, which is linked to serious health conditions […] It helps young people to access affordable housing and also to help seniors combat loneliness […] No Isolation (founded in 2015) that is on a mission to reduce social isolation and involuntary loneliness through communication tools […]
1
Boris Johnson urged to make UK a ‘world leader’ in Housing-with-Care | News
hqnetwork.co.uk – Today
[…] as diverse as Age UK, Legal & General, the British Property Federation, the Campaign to End Loneliness and the County Councils Network, as well as the country’s largest not-for-profit providers of car […]
0
BwD Help Hub for residents | Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council
blackburn.gov.uk – Today
[…] can help people with: finance, benefits and debt management mental health support wellbeing and loneliness learning, training and employment getting online and using technology access to food and essentials […]
681
Long-term Effects of COVID-19 in Adolescents – Full Text View – ClinicalTrials.gov
clinicaltrials.gov – Today
[…] pulmonary and cognitive assessement; a questionnaire charting symptoms, emotionality, personality, loneliness, life events and demographics; and extensive biobanking including genetic markers, viable PBMC […]
0
Carrying naloxone can save lives but newly abstinent opioid users resist
researchnews.cc – Today
[…] of a supermassive black hole • Does selfishness evolve? Ask a cannibal • Wisdom, loneliness and your intestinal multitude • Australian team gets to the heart of COVID-19 • Control syste […]
0
Boarding School During Covid – The New York Times
[…] Students who feel homesick have to weather the loneliness alone since most family visits have been canceled […]
2
COVID-19 (2019 novel coronavirus) resource center for physicians
[…] —Ethics Talk Videocast: White Coats for Black Lives —Ethics Talk Videocast: Social Isolation, Loneliness, and COVID-19 —Ethics Talk Videocast: COVID-19 Pandemic and the Global Climate Crisis —Ethics Tal […]
15
Team studies new use for pulmonary hypertension drug
researchnews.cc – Today
[…] of a supermassive black hole • Does selfishness evolve? Ask a cannibal • Wisdom, loneliness and your intestinal multitude • Australian team gets to the heart of COVID-19 • Control syste […]
0
Personal Assistant
[…] Some support is about having a chat and a cup of tea with people, as loneliness can cause a decline in mental health and wellbeing […]
0
My home helper
[…] Photos Instant Messaging News Headlines We know that the support from Amica 24 can help combat loneliness, support people living with dementia as well as lots of other benefits all helping you or you […]
0
Coronavirus and our mental wellbeing
[…] a strong support network can help you through difficult times in life and can combat feelings of loneliness or isolation […]
183
Fast-acting, color-changing molecular probe senses when a material is about to fail
researchnews.cc – Today
[…] of a supermassive black hole • Does selfishness evolve? Ask a cannibal • Wisdom, loneliness and your intestinal multitude • Australian team gets to the heart of COVID-19 • Control syste […]
N/A
Labour want mental health workers in every GP surgery
news.stv.tv – Today
[…] It also identified a rise in those suffering loneliness and feelings of hopelessness in the past year […]
N/A
CJ Hall
[…] Along with the drawn out pandemic and the loneliness it’s brought to many, it’s also possible to experience that isolation when no one gives you th […]
N/A
Anna by Niccolò Ammaniti
[…] Exploration of modern themes of loneliness, abandonment, and self-discovery […]
9
Empathetic Marketing: The Secret Business Ingredient in the 2021 Recipe
rankedia.com – Today
[…] That means your audience is missing out on traveling and meeting people, and is dealing with loneliness and uncertainty […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: