If you have some money invested in mutual funds, using them to pay off debt may seem like an attractive option. You may assume that you’ll get more benefit from using the money that you’ve invested to eliminate debt (and the associated high interest rates). But cashing in your mutual funds may not be the best way to become debt-free if there are other options available. And depending on where you hold your mutual funds, you could end up receiving a steep tax bill.
- Cashing out mutual funds may not be the best option for repaying debt.
- You may owe capital gains tax on mutual funds that you cash out from a taxable brokerage account.
- Cashing out mutual funds from an IRA or other qualified retirement account could trigger income tax on earnings, as well as an early withdrawal tax penalty.
- Withdrawing money from your investments to pay debt means missing out on future growth from compounding interest.
Pros and Cons of Cashing Out Mutual Funds to Pay Off Debt
Using mutual funds to pay off debt may seem appealing at first glance. If you aren’t using the money that you’ve invested for any particular financial goal, then why not use it to pay off credit cards, student loans, or other debts? After all, eliminating debt can free up more money in your budget that you can then reinvest in mutual funds, stocks, or other securities.However, there are some problems with that logic.
Specifically, there are two major drawbacks associated with cashing out mutual funds to pay down debt. The first is taxes; the second is how it may negatively impact your long-term financial goals.In terms of tax implications, there are two ways that cashing out mutual funds to pay debt can backfire, depending on where you hold them. If you have mutual funds in a taxable brokerage account, then cashing them out may trigger capital gains tax if you’re selling them above what you initially paid for them.
Short-term capital gains on securities owned for less than one year are subject to ordinary income tax rates.1 The long-term capital gains tax rate is 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your income.
If you hold mutual funds inside an individual retirement account (IRA), then you can avoid capital gains tax. But you may pay ordinary income tax on earnings, as well as a 10% early withdrawal penalty, depending on the type of IRA, how long you’ve had the account, and your age at the time of withdrawal.
If the mutual funds are in an IRA, you may pay ordinary income tax on the entire withdrawal, the exception would be if you had any basis in your IRA. Then a 10% penalty may apply. The rules are slightly different for Roth IRAs, especially when it comes to taxes.
Aside from the tax consequences of using mutual funds to pay down debt, it’s also important to consider how it may impact your ability to grow wealth. By selling off mutual funds and not replacing them with other investments, you miss out on the power of compounding interest. Depending on how much of your mutual fund holdings you choose to sell, that could mean losing thousands of dollars in growth over time.
If you’re considering cashing out mutual funds in a brokerage account, use an online capital gains tax calculator to estimate how much you may owe on the sale.
Other Options for Paying Off Debt
Cashing out mutual funds isn’t the only way to manage debt. There are other possibilities for eliminating debt faster while also saving money on interest, including:
- Refinancing student loans, personal loans, or other loans at a lower interest rate
- Consolidating credit card debts into a single personal loan
- Taking advantage of 0% credit card balance transfer offers
- Using a home equity loan to consolidate debts
- Selling vehicles or other non-investment assets that you own and applying the proceeds to your debt balances
If you’re struggling with debt repayment, then you may consider other options, such as a debt management plan or debt settlement. With a debt management plan, you work with a certified credit counselor to create a plan for paying off what’s owed. This may include reducing interest rates or fees. You make a single payment to the credit counselor, who then distributes the funds among your creditors.
Debt settlement is something that you may consider for past-due debts. This involves working with a consumer debt specialist to negotiate debts with creditors. The goal is to pay off debts for less than what’s owed to avoid filing for bankruptcy as a last resort.
Making an Informed Decision
If you’re considering selling mutual funds to pay off debt, it’s important to do your research beforehand. Your broker or financial advisor can provide you with the expected rate of return for a mutual fund going forward. Compare this rate to the fund’s historical performance to ensure its accuracy. If the mutual funds pay dividends, then this amount should be included in the assessment. If funds are held within a retirement account, find out the fees and penalties for cashing out.
Again, cashing out of a traditional IRA before age 59½ results in a 10%, or 25% if you have a SIMPLE IRA, tax penalty. There are exceptions for withdrawals, such as disability, medical debt, certain educational expenses, and buying a home. Mutual funds held within regular brokerage accounts have the standard commission charges, but the fund itself still may charge a fee for redeeming your shares. Brokers and financial advisors are great resources for this information.
The interest rate on your debt and the length of the loan should provide the last pieces of evidence to make an informed decision. Debts such as credit cards and short-term loans typically have higher interest rates than longer-term debts such as vehicle loans or mortgages. For mortgages, check to make sure that you have a fixed interest rate. Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) can keep increasing over time and lead to payments that might balloon above your ability to repay them.
A 401(k) loan also is an option for repaying debt, but if you separate from your job before the loan is repaid, then the entire amount could be treated as a taxable distribution.
The Bottom Line
While becoming debt-free may be relief, there are some downsides to consider if you’re using mutual funds to achieve that goal. Fees and penalties are red flags when thinking about cashing in your mutual funds. Loss of future investment income and the lack of a retirement account can put you in a worse situation later in life.
You can make additional debt payments using current income to shorten the length of the loan and reduce the total amount of interest that you have to pay, assuming your budget allows it. If you’re truly struggling with how to repay debt, then consider reaching out to debt relief companies to see how they may be able to help.
When researching debt relief companies, be sure to get a clear explanation of the services that they offer and the fees that you might have to pay before signing a contract for services.
Compete Risk Free with $100,000 in Virtual Cash
Put your trading skills to the test with our FREE Stock Simulator. Compete with thousands of Investopedia traders and trade your way to the top! Submit trades in a virtual environment before you start risking your own money. Practice trading strategies so that when you’re ready to enter the real market, you’ve had the practice you need.
By: Nathan Buehler
Nathan Buehler is a well-established writer on the VIX and its related exchange traded products. Nathan also provides coverage on publicly traded companies, commodities, and personal finance/budgeting. Not only is Nathan a writer, but he is also a teacher. His drive to help others doesn’t end in the classroom. This is evident by the time and commitment he gives to his readers through personal feedback and open discussion of topics. He has written articles on topics such as economics, investing, and finance.
- Superior Court of Pennsylvania (1894). “Brooke et al versus the City of Philadelphia et al”. Weekly Notes of Cases Argued and Determined in the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, the County Courts of Philadelphia, and the United States District and Circuit Courts for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Kay and brother. 34 (18): 348.
- “debt”. Oxford English Dictionary (Online ed.). Oxford University Press. (Subscription or participating institution membership required.)
- Do payment mechanisms change the way consumers perceive products? Journal of Consumer Research, 38(6), 1129–1139.
- Monopoly money: The effect of payment coupling and form on spending behavior Archived 15 February 2015 at the Wayback Machine. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 14 (3), 213–25.
- The effect of payment transparency on consumption: Quasi experiments from the field. Marketing Letters, 14, 173–183.
- “Household over-indebtedness in the EU: The role of informal debts” (PDF). eurofound.europa.eu. Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg. 2013. Retrieved 19 April 2016.
- Using Revenue-Based Financing to Grow Your Business”. Business News Daily. Retrieved 5 December 2018.
- America and the Global Economy, Foreign Affairs, May/June 2016.
- “Goal 17 | Department of Economic and Social Affairs”. sdgs.un.org. Retrieved 26 September 2020.
- Debt Management Strategies of Local Governments in the EU”. Pro Publico Bono – Magyar Közigazgatás. 8: 146–169 – via REAL-MTAK.
- Managing household debts: Social service provision in the EU. Working paper. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions” (PDF). European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions. Retrieved 20 February 2015.
- Hudson, Michael (2018). …and Forgive Them Their Debts: Lending, Foreclosure and Redemption From Bronze Age Finance to the Jubilee Year. Islet. ISBN 978-3981826029.
- “Jubilee USA: Debt Cancellation: A Biblical Norm”. http://www.jubileeusa.org. Retrieved 22 September 2020.