Do financial traders make better returns in the stock market when they are well rested? You would intuitively assume that a trader’s level of sleep would affect their decision making.
Several studies have certainly shown that sleep affects the ability of people to make decisions in general. Though admittedly based on small samples of participants, these studies show that those who are short on sleep tend to have relatively low attention to detail, poor memory, poor performance and significant mood swings.
But when it comes to whether sleep affects financial decisions, the evidence has been mixed. The only measure of sleepiness that has been used is the annual clock changes for daylight saving that take place in many countries, since they disturb many people’s sleep. A few studies have used this to look at how stock market returns are affected on the Mondays directly after the clocks go back or forward by an hour.
One such study in 2000 concluded that returns were relatively low when traders lacked sleep, and suggested that the lack of sleep might make them more risk-averse because they were anxious and struggling to concentrate. But later studies, such as this one from 2002, suggested that the correlation between sleep and cautious investing might not be as strong empirically as initially thought.
Daylight-saving time changes have the advantage that we all have to adjust them, but they are far from an ideal proxy for sleep since they only occur twice a year, and the impact on people’s sleep is relatively small since the clock only changes by an hour. This might explain why the research evidence has been mixed in this area.
To try and improve our understanding in this area, I undertook a pilot study of a fund manager in England, analysing his investment transactions in the context of sleep data that he recorded in a diary.
I found that his sleep patterns did indeed influence his investment decisions. In line with the theory from the 2000 study, the fund manager made fewer transactions when he was short on sleep.
To see whether there was a wider correlation, I sought to develop a new proxy for sleep. We know that around 80% of people search for information online about their health issues, and there is no reason to believe that investors behave any differently. I also knew that Google data has been used by researchers to measure investor attention to individual stocks.
I therefore created a sleepiness index based on the extent to which people in the US were searching Google for 28 relevant terms including “sleep deprivation”, “sleeping pills” and “jet lag cure”. Some of these terms came from allowing the Google algorithm to offer up potential sleepiness terms based on suggested autocompletes.
The more that people searched for things to do with sleepiness, the greater the indication of sleep difficulties. Unlike the time changes from daylight saving, my index has the advantage of being based on daily data, and can measure a much wider range of sleepiness. To test its validity, I checked the index against times that we would normally associate with sleepiness, including daylight-saving time changes and also sunrises and sunsets. Sure enough, sleepiness-related Google searches increase at these times.
The index confirmed that stock-market returns are indeed quite low on days that traders are short on sleep. For every 1% daily increase in sleep difficulties across the population, stock-market returns fell by 0.14%. I also found that these patterns reversed on subsequent days, which may mean that traders realise that their initial decisions were poor and take steps to correct them.
What next from a research point of view? Researchers could potentially use the data from sleep apps to get more accurate measures of the relationship between stock market returns and the population’s sleepiness over time. No doubt the better we understand this, the more that traders will be able to use it to their advantage.
My work is another example of how online search data can shed new light on old research subjects. There are surely lots of other ways in which the academic community can use it to understand other factors that influence our decisions.
By: Antonios Siganos Senior Lecturer in Finance, University of Glasgow
Harmonium Sleep Support – The Top Sleep Supplement On CB
sites.google.com – Today[…] Crisis Led To A Shocking “Backyard” Tea Discovery That’s Now Helping Thousands Of Exhausted, Sleep-deprived 3 A […]18
Revision Supplement Review – Improving Your Eyesight & Memory Fast.
http://www.reviewsgoal.com – Today[…] If you are sleep-deprived, then you do not need to worry at all […]0
Tips on preparing for the switch to Daylight Saving Time
http://www.citynews1130.com – Today[…] ” Lu says those who are already sleep-deprived and children who rely on strict routines will be hardest hit […]2
The World According to Michael Coorlim
player.captivate.fm – Today[…] You know when you start feeling sleep deprived, how the world doesn’t feel real anymore? But then we figured out the cost to actually produce th […]N/A
ipccontent.advisorstream.com – Today[…] in order to get more things done or to rely on a cup (or more) of coffee to keep you going when sleep deprived […]0
Your Daylight Saving Time Questions Answered – The New York Times
http://www.nytimes.com – Today[…] “Not only are we sleep deprived but we’re trying to force our brain into a little bit more of an unnatural sleep schedule,” said Dr […]4
Acknowledging Preindustrial Patterns of Sleep May Revolutionize Approach to Sleep Dysfunction
http://www.psychiatrictimes.com – Today[…] that under our current conditions, we may fall asleep so quickly because we are chronically sleep-deprived […] Are we chronically sleep deprived? Bull Psychonomic Soc […]2
‘Almost inhumane’: Treating the complex problem of physician fatigue
http://www.tvo.org – Today[…] I completely forgot to check on this, because I was so sleep-deprived […]5
Chick-fil-A Opens In Linden: Top News Of The Week | Clark, NJ Patch
patch.com – Today[…] Aside from being sleep deprived, she finds this […]1
6 ways to feel less tired after daylight saving 2021
http://www.reviewed.com – Today[…] “We tend to crave sweets when we’re sleep-deprived,” Aronson says […]1
As Bipartisan Bill Moves To End Daylight Saving Time, A Review Of Why It’s So Bad For Our Health
gothamist.com – Today[…] even more: this Mayo Clinic found that DST could lead to “an increase in medical errors” because of sleep-deprived healthcare workers […]7
Belfast named as UK’s most sleep-deprived city – BelfastTelegraph.co.uk
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk – Today[…] In a report compiled by a UK mattress firm, Belfast was picked as the most sleep-deprived city in the UK […] Between the start of 2020 and 2021, searches for sleep-deprived terms were said to have increased by nearly a third (30%) […]15
Four incredible benefits of CBD oil for dogs – FingerLakes1.com
bestcann.com – Today[…] When serotonin levels are low, canines become sleep-deprived, unhappy, and less sociable […]N/A
We must work together to make kitchens more inclusive
http://www.sodexo.com – Today[…] a global movement fighting for a more resilient and sustainable industry, 74% of chefs feel sleep deprived to the point of exhaustion; 53% of chefs feel pushed to breaking point; and 1 in 4 chefs ha […]0
Review Finds LAPD Failures Led to Mishandling of Summer Civil Unrest
http://www.asisonline.org – March 12[…] If they are sleep deprived, decision making could be impacted, which then has the potential to affect the success of th […]0
10 WEIGHT LOSS Life Hacks to LOSE WEIGHT FAST and EASY! (Tips That Actually Work)
thebestwaystoloseweight.net – March 12[…] habits can cause you to gain weight for one your metabolism does not function properly when you’re sleep-deprived secondly “youve had” the starvation hormone ghrelin that tells you when to eat when you hav […]0
Large cognitive fluctuations surrounding sleep in daily living
http://www.cell.com – March 12[…] Body posture affects electroencephalographic activity and psychomotor vigilance task performance in sleep-deprived subjects […] Cognitive performance, sleepiness, and mood in partially sleep deprived adolescents: the need for sleep study […]0
Light painting 101: Five easy steps to illuminating cyanide tanks carved with guerrilla art
photofocus.com – March 12[…] to weird music, stay out all night creating photos, get dirty, hang out with other creative sleep-deprived weirdos, see the stars drift across the sky and always find the best taco stands whil […]3
A year of the pandemic in your words – the examined family
courtney.substack.com – March 12[…] I have felt a deep darkness I have only experienced once before in my life, when chronically sleep deprived after my second child was born and wouldn’t sleep through the night for a year and a half […]2
Belfast people have more trouble sleeping than anywhere else in the UK, new study shows
http://www.irishpost.com – March 12[…] The study found that for every 100,000 people in Belfast, sleep-deprived terms were searched for 1,931 times […]1
5 reasons we won’t be giving up our weekend lie-ins right now
http://www.independent.co.uk – March 12[…] However, if it becomes a ‘need to have’ because we’re sleep deprived during the week, that’s a concern […]2
J.K. – Identity Crisis – Track by Track
1883magazine.com – March 12[…] I actually initiated the writing of this song when I was extremely sleep deprived, and I almost forgot (while compiling the track list) that I wrote it […]0
Sleep maximizes vaccine effectiveness
medicalxpress.com – March 12[…] Up to 10 days later, the sleep-deprived individuals possessed half the number of vaccine antibodies than the non-sleep-deprived controls […]N/A
Sleep Maximizes Vaccine Effectiveness
http://www.newswise.com – March 12[…] Up to 10 days later, the sleep-deprived individuals possessed half the number of vaccine antibodies than the non-sleep-deprived controls […]N/A
Mental health and alcohol/drug use during the COVID-19 pandemic
positivechoices.org.au – March 12[…] “Let’s talk about sleep”: a qualitative examination of levers for promoting healthy sleep among sleep-deprived vulnerable adolescents […]145