Understanding The Research & Development Tax Credit – What Small Businesses Need To Know

Three women and two men in a business meeting.

It’s tax season, let the sales pitches begin! Tax return preparation companies and do-it-yourself software providers are hard at work convincing individual taxpayers that their services and products are the way to maximize a tax refund or pay the lowest amount of tax. And, judging by what I’m seeing on social media, companies that specialize in the Credit for Increasing Research Activities (also known as the R&D tax credit) are also selling hard, looking for businesses who may qualify for this credit—especially startups.

They are casting an extremely wide net. While it’s true that the R&D credit is often overlooked by small businesses and their return preparers, it’s not as easy to qualify for the credit as some of these companies want small business owners to believe. Buyer beware.

For sole proprietorships, partnerships, and S-corporations the R&D credit is claimed by filing Form 6765 with the business return (Schedule C of a Form 1040, Form 1065, or Form 1120-S, respectively). Qualifying small businesses can elect an up to $250,000 payroll tax credit instead of an income tax credit.

I’m not going to get into the mechanics of taking the credits here but it is easy to see how this election could benefit a startup in the early stages with payroll expenses and the associated taxes but not much income to be taxed. Nevertheless, the mere fact that a business is new or has a new product does not automatically make expenses qualified research expenses for the purposes of this credit.

Section 174 of the Internal Revenue Code allows a taxpayer to treat “research or experimental expenditures” as expenses instead of having to amortize them over 60 months. The R&D credit uses the same definition of research or experimental expenditures as IRC Section 174. Qualified research expenses are defined in Treasury Regulation 1.174-2. The expenditures must be “incurred in connection with the taxpayer’s trade or business” and must “represent research and development costs in the experimental or the laboratory sense.”

The regulation goes on to state that “expenditures represent research and development costs in the experimental or laboratory sense if they are for activities intended to discover information that would eliminate uncertainty concerning the development or improvement of a product.” Additionally, qualification depends on the “nature of the activity to which the expenditures relate, not the nature of the product or improvement being developed.” It is on these semantic rocks that many tax credit ships have foundered.

In Connection With The Taxpayer’s Trade or Business

For an expenditure to be incurred in connection with a trade or business, the business must be a functioning business. Deductions exist for startup expenses for businesses but those should not be confused with the R&D credit.

Research activities conducted before a business is a business may be legitimate (and deductible) startup expenses but they do not qualify for the R&D credit. In other words, you must start your startup and then do the research, not develop the product and build the business around it in order for research expenditures to be considered qualifying expenses for the R&D credit.

The Experimental Or The Laboratory Sense

To qualify, research and development expenditures must be paid to eliminate uncertainty concerning the development or improvement of a product. This concept is perhaps best described as traditional trial and error using the scientific method. The idea of evaluating alternatives is important as is systematic testing of various alternatives. Testing and debugging an existing product is not enough to qualify for the credit. Neither is evaluating a set of alternatives or features for a given product.

For example, research to determine which set of code objects are necessary to implement a given software solution would not qualify. Quality control and assurance testing is also specifically excluded. A taxpayer must be evaluating alternatives to create a new product or improve an existing product. Additionally, the improvement must be related to the product’s performance and not simply a matter of cosmetics, taste, or fashion. Perhaps the best example of qualifying expenses would be those incurred to develop and test prototypes of a new product.

What about software and app development? What indeed. Determining whether software development costs are qualified research expenditures requires special analysis. Expenses incurred to develop software for internal use are specifically excluded from qualification. In Accounting Standard Codification (ASC) 730, the IRS Large Business & International unit indicated that internal use software includes software “used to provide a service or produce a product that the customer neither acquires nor gains any right to future use of.”

That is, the expenses incurred to develop a customized user experience for your website’s shopping cart will not qualify where expenses incurred to develop and test a new game for a gaming company to sell, most likely would—at least up to the point that “technological feasibility is established” (again, according to ASC 730).

The Nature Of The Activities Not The Nature Of The Product

For expenditures to qualify substantially all (substantially all has been defined as 80%) of the research activities must relate to a process of experimentation for a new or improved product. Corn Island Shipyard, Inc. recently found this out the hard way when the U.S. Tax Court ruled that the 80% requirement was not satisfied “simply because at least 80% of the product’s elements differ from those of the products the taxpayer previously developed.”

The ruling in Little Sandy Coal Company, Inc., v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (T.C. Memo 2021-15) held that the “substantially all” test applied to activities, not to physical components of the product being developed or improved. In other words, even though the company’s two products (a ship and a dry dock) were 80% different from the company’s other products, because the research activities involved in developing the two new products did not comprise 80% of the research and development activities the expenses did not qualify for the credit.

Developing the two new products only required a small amount of actual experimentation to create a substantially different product. And, for the purposes of this credit, it’s the activities that count, not the product.

The R&D credit can be an excellent benefit for small companies, especially those who are developing new products or product lines. Nevertheless, the rules for claiming the credit are complex and nuanced. Correctly claiming the credit may be beyond the skills of many tax professionals who serve small companies. If you think your company may qualify for the credit it can be a good idea to work with a company that specializes in qualifying companies and determining qualifying expenses.

Those companies should be willing to work with your tax professional (and vice versa). Startup owners should, however, proceed with caution when it comes to firms with big marketing budgets and great sales pitches that promise to qualify them for this credit without knowing anything about the company or its products. There be (tax) dragons.

Follow me on Twitter.
https://i1.wp.com/onlinemarketingscoops.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/3jM-I6UL_400x400.jpg?resize=102%2C102&ssl=1

I own Tax Therapy, LLC, in Albuquerque, New Mexico. I am an Enrolled Agent and non-attorney practitioner admitted to the bar of the U.S. Tax Court. I work as a tax general practitioner preparing returns for individuals and (really) small businesses as well as representing individuals before the IRS and, occasionally, the U.S. Tax Court. My passion is translating “taxspeak” into English for taxpayers and tax practitioners. I write to dispel myths with facts and to explain “the fine print” behind seemingly simple tax concepts. I cover individual tax issues and IRS developments with a focus on items of interest to taxpayers and retail tax practitioners. Follow me on Twitter @taxtherapist505

Source: Understanding The Research & Development Tax Credit – What Small Businesses Need To Know

.

.

More Contents:

How benefits like CERB affect your taxes | Sun Life
[…] Here are a few that you get to keep tax-free: Disability Tax Credit (DTC), Goods and Services Tax Credit (GSTC), Canada Child Benefit (CCB), and Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) payments […]
1
Covid-19 Live Updates: U.S. Awaits F.D.A.’s Green Light for Johnson & Johnson’s Single-Shot Vaccine – The New York Times
[…] payments to $400 a week from $300 and extending them through the end of August Increase the child tax credit Provide more than $50 billion for vaccine distribution, testing and tracing Allocate nearly $20 […]
N/A
Bennet Applauds House Passage of Biden American Rescue Plan | Press Releases | U.S. Senator
[…] That’s why I fought for the American Rescue Plan to include my proposals to expand the Child Tax Credit and Earned Income Tax Credit, which will cut child poverty in half and provide economic security to millions of families […] ”   Along with expanding the Child Tax Credit (CTC) and Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Bennet fought tirelessly to secure other Colorado priorities in Biden’s plan […]
4
Live: Coronavirus daily news updates, February 27: What to know today about COVID-19 in the Seattle area, Washington state and the world
[…] It would increase the child tax credit; provide more than $50 billion for vaccine distribution, testing and tracing; and allocate nearl […]
N/A
Important reminders before filing 2020 tax returns | Internal Revenue Service
[…] Earned Income Tax Credit The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) can give qualifying workers with low-to-moderate income a substantial financial boost […] Taxpayers also have the option of using their 2019 income to figure the Additional Child Tax Credit for 2020 […]
36
House works late, OKs stimulus bill
[…] said as part of the plan, very small businesses “with middle-class owners” would receive an income tax credit to cover 25% of their employees’ wages, up to $10,000 per year per employer, in an effort t […]
N/A
Republicans said $2.3 trillion for wealthy’s OK but $1.9 trillion for you It’s too much. READ THIS!
[…] An expansion of the child tax credit to give families up to $3,600 per child over a year $20 billion for Covid-19 vaccine distributio […]
N/A
Opinion | My 6 Months as a Solo Parent – The New York Times
[…] President Biden has offered a proposal to expand the child tax credit […]
2
Republicans said $2.3 T for wealthy & corps OK but $1.9 T not OK for you
egbertowillies.com – Today
[…] An expansion of the child tax credit to give families up to $3,600 per child over a year $20 billion for Covid-19 vaccine distributio […]
2
Services
[…] We have participated in Section 501(c)(3) bond offerings, housing tax credit projects, and public-private partnership transactions […] Go To Top Housing Tax Credit Services MUCR provides a comprehensive range of services to the affordable housing industry […] Our success in tax credit projects is based on our ability to work with your development team which includes attorneys […]
N/A
House Approves Biden’s $1.9T Pandemic Relief Package – Law360
[…] The bill would also increase the child tax credit to $3,000 in certain cases, or $3,600 for children under age 6; expand eligibility for the earne […] in certain cases, or $3,600 for children under age 6; expand eligibility for the earned income tax credit; and extend credits to reimburse employers for workers’ paid sick leave, among other tax changes […] over time on big corporations’ payrolls if they fail to meet a certain wage standard, paired with a tax credit equal to 25% of wages to small businesses that pay workers higher wages, capped at $10,000 per year […]
0
Stimulus Package Could Mean $14,000 Windfall for Family of Four
[…] Added to this would be extra money under the revamped Child Tax Credit […]
2
Rep. Veasey (TX-33) Votes to Pass the Biden American Rescue Plan to Deliver Urgent Relief to the American People
veasey.house.gov – Today
[…] American workers can pay their bills and supporting 27 million children with an expanded Child Tax Credit and 15 million low-wage workers through the Earned Income Tax Credit […]
2
House Passes $1.9 Trillion Pork-Filled COVID ‘Relief’ Package. Here’s What It Includes. by Beth Baumann
townhall.com – Today
[…] Keep Democrats from Packing the Supreme Court Bronson Stocking In addition, the bill ups the child tax credit to $3,600 for children six and under […]
169
House Passes Blue Pork ‘COVID-19 Relief’ Bill – PJ Media
pjmedia.com – Today
[…] The bill increases the child tax credit from $2,000 to $3,000 (a cost of $99 billion) and expands the Earned Income Tax Credit to some childless adults ($25 billion) […]
3
Larson Votes for Critical COVID Relief
larson.house.gov – Today
[…]   Cuts child poverty in half by Increasing the Child Tax Credit to $3,000 per child age 6 and over/$3,600 for children under age 6 […]   Expands the Earned Income Tax Credit for workers, including working seniors for the first time […]   Expands the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit and makes it fully refundable to help families afford child care […]
1
Electric bikes could get much cheaper under a new proposal from two House Democrats
[…] – introduced the Electric Bicycle Incentive Kickstart for the Environment (E-BIKE) Act, a tax-credit program that aims to spur e-bike sales […] It resembles a federal tax credit program that gives buyers of certain low- and zero-emission cars a rebate worth up to $7,500 […]
N/A
Meng Helps Pass Nearly $2 Trillion American Rescue Plan Act
meng.house.gov – Today
[…] from the last relief bill – bringing the total relief payment to $2,000 per person; Make the child tax credit fully refundable for 2021 and increases the annual amount from the current $2,000 per child t […]
1
Financial Impact of a Caregiving Experience Survey
[…] $3,000 tax credit to working family caregivers for qualified expenses Annual stipend of $1,200 Career coaching t […]
0
2021 Economic Aid Act Impact on Small Businesses
[…] for your business to accommodate these new legislative opportunities About the Employee Retention Tax Credit for businesses, now available to PPP borrowers Documentation best practices to mitigate issues fo […]
0
Finance Law for 2021 – discover the highlights
[…] starting January 1, 2022 Expenses outsourced to State bodies will not be doubled anymore in the tax credit computation They will be limited to 3 times the amount of other expenses included in the tax credit computation The total annual limit for external expenses has been reduced to 10 M€ Tax credit related to energy renovation of professional buildings New tax credit for expenses improving th […]
N/A
Slotkin Votes to Advance COVID Relief Bill
slotkin.house.gov – Today
[…]   Expands the Child Tax Credit and the Earned Income Tax Credit and increases the amount families are eligible to receive for both, putting money in the pockets of […]
2
Golden Statement on Vote Against $1.9 Trillion Legislative Package | by Congressman Jared Golden | Feb, 2021
repgolden.medium.com – Today
[…] $250 billion in these kinds of provisions, including a one-year expansion of the Child Tax Credit, a two-year enhancement of premium subsidies under the Affordable Care Act, and multiemploye […]
1
Colorado hangs hopes on electric vehicle mass shift to combat climate warming
[…] Two parents dropped in with their twin 17-year-old daughters, learned that a state tax credit was about to shrink from $4,000 to $2,500, and snapped up a pair of Leafs, saying the colors didn’t […]
5
Biden Administration Passes $1.9 Trillion Stimulus Package
coingape.com – Today
[…] of programs making millions of more people eligible for jobless benefits An expansion of the child tax credit to give families up to $3,600 per child over a year $20 billion for Covid-19 vaccine distributio […]
4
Support A Capital Gains Tax and Working Family Tax Credit!
fusewashington.actionkit.com – Today
Tell your legislators they must start to balance Washington’s tax code by passing a capital gains tax and funding the Working Families Tax Credit!
8
PI’s Media Digest: 10 US cities that will spend more on police than public health in 2021; how community health providers can support equitable vaccine rollout | Prevention Institute
preventioninstitute.org – Today
[…] hike, $1400 stimulus checks, supplemental unemployment benefits, and increase in the Child Tax Credit, and aid to states for testing and vaccination campaigns […]
0
Reducing Unintended Consequences: Integrated EPC for Solar and Storage
blog.burnsmcd.com – Today
[…]   Driven by tax credit programs, renewable mandates and other market-specific incentives, interest in solar is high […]
N/A
House passes Biden’s US$1.9 trillion COVID relief package | CTV News
[…] $1,400 direct checks to Americans making less than $75,000 annually, an increase in the child tax credit, direct funding to state and local governments, funding for schools and more money for vaccin […]
N/A
Biden’s Covid-19 relief bill including stimulus checks passes the House
[…] Affordable Care Act subsidies for low- and middle-income Americans and expands both the child tax credit and the earned income tax credit […] Some provisions, such as higher ACA subsidies, the expanded child tax credit, and the expanded earned income tax credit, are only temporary, and it’s unclear whether they’ll last beyond the next year or two […]
2
Tax credit proposal is really a plan for private school vouchers in Kentucky
[…] (House Bill 205 in 2019), which, had it been successful, would have allowed a significant income tax credit to donors in exchange for students’ private school tuition assistance […] Opportunity Account Program (EOA Program), which will be funded by an individual or corporate tax credit […] The tax credit rate of 95%, combined with a maximum tax credit amount of $1 million, may also alter the dynamic of who controls education funding […]
1
Text – H.R.1319 – 117th Congress (2021-2022): American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 | Congress.gov | Library of Congress
[…] PART 2—CHILD TAX CREDIT Sec. 9611. Child tax credit improvements for 2021. Sec. 9612. Application of child tax credit in possessions. Sec. 9621. Strengthening the earned income tax credit for individuals with no qualifying children […] Temporary special rule for determining earned income for purposes of earned income tax credit. Sec. 9631. Refundability and enhancement of child and dependent care tax credit […]
21
New webpages and webinar posted to help small employers choose and maintain a retirement plan
content.govdelivery.com – Today
[…] Small employers may receive a tax credit for new plans of up to $5,000/year for three years for the cost of setting up a new plan […]
3
Biden’s $1.9 trillion COVID relief bill passes House, but faces Senate hurdle – CBS News
[…] My plan would provide an income tax credit equal to 25 percent of wages, up to $10,000 per year per employer, to small businesses that pa […]
5
House Passes $1.9 Trillion COVID-19 Relief Bill
[…] funding for schools, additional money for vaccine distribution, and an increase to the child tax credit The measure now heads to the Senate, where members are currently debating how to proceed followin […] funding for schools, additional money for vaccine distribution, and an increase to the child tax credit […]
5
Budget 2021: What we know, what to look out for and how it affects you
[…] Peston, the Treasury is reluctant to make the top up permanent because, with the knock-on impact on tax credit, it costs around £6 billion a year […]
43
Stimulus Package Passed by House a ‘Missed Opportunity’ Says Mitch McConnell
[…] for state and local governments, $130 billion to help K-12 schools reopen and expanding the child tax credit to $3,000 per child or $3,600 for children under six […]
7
Research and development Edinburgh : Geoghegans
[…] range of tax incentives including an increased deduction for R&D revenue spending and a payable R&D tax credit for companies not in profit […] than €86m The incentives include: increased deduction for R&D revenue spending and a payable R&D tax credit for companies not in profit […]
1
Americans can’t file their income taxes fast enough — but they should brace for some unwelcome news in their 2020 refunds
[…] The refunds as of now don’t factor in refunds that include payments for the Earned Income Tax Credit, a powerful anti-poverty tax credit geared toward low- and moderate-income families […] Refunds incorporating the EITC and the Additional Child Tax Credit will start hitting bank accounts during the first week of March, according to the IRS […]
0
About Us – UPI Loan Fund
upiloanfund.us – Today
[…] He has created profit/non-profit partnerships for Low Income Housing Tax Credit projects along with asset and property management activities including the refinancing an […]
0
Last Few Days to Apply for Small Business Hiring Tax Credit
Sacramento – There’s still time for small business owners to receive financial help by applying for the Main Street Small Business Hiring Tax Credit (https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/taxes-and-fees/SB1447-tax-credit.htm).
N/A
Global Medical Tubing Market – Foster Market Research
[…] has kept its R&D tax credit low […]
N/A
There are new rules this tax season, courtesy of COVID-19. Here’s what you need to know
maroc.us – Today
[…] Multiply that by $2 a day and he’s set to get a tax credit of $376 […] ” Digital tax credit Golombek also points out one of the new wrinkles this tax season, which is that the government i […]
1
Senate Democrats move immediately to “Plan B” on minimum wage – CBS News
[…] who earn less than $15 per hour would qualify for a “Blue Collar Bonus” in the form of an automatic tax credit […]
N/A
MyAnimeList.net
myanimelist.net – Today
[…] It would also increase the value of the so-called child tax credit and provide more than $50 billion for vaccine distribution, testing and tracing, nearly $20 […]
0
HOT JOBS & COOL JOBS: EXERCISE SPECIALIST REDMOND WA USA
[…] Apply Now>> 27 Compliance Auditor – Tax Credit Specialist! Seattle, WA, USA Motivation – you are internally driven and can exercise sound judgment […]
0
Accelerating Digital Transformation | by Ali Jan | Feb, 2021
medium.com – Today
[…] do to accelerate digital transformation: Invest In The Digital Future The government must give tax credit and investment funds to startups to continue innovating in an increasingly competitive digita […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: