We Can’t Fight Climate Change Without Valuing Nature

new study in Nature Sustainability incorporates the damages that climate change does to healthy ecosystems into standard climate-economics models. The key finding in the study by Bernardo Bastien-Olvera and Frances Moore from the University of California at Davis: The models have been underestimating the cost of climate damages to society by a factor of more than five.

Their study concludes that the most cost-effective emissions pathway results in just 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) additional global warming by 2100, consistent with the “aspirational” objective of the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement.

Models that combine climate science and economics, called “integrated assessment models” (IAMs), are critical tools in developing and implementing climate policies and regulations. In 2010, an Obama administration governmental interagency working group used IAMs to establish the social cost of carbon – the first federal estimates of climate damage costs caused by carbon pollution. That number guides federal agencies required to consider the costs and benefits of proposed regulations.

Economic models of climate have long been criticized by those convinced they underestimate the costs of climate damages, in some cases to a degree that climate scientists consider absurd.

Given the importance of the social cost of carbon to federal rulemaking, some critics have complained that the Trump EPA used what they see as creative accounting to slash the government’s estimate of the number. In one of his inauguration day Executive Orders, President Biden established a new Interagency Working Group to re-evaluate the social cost of all greenhouse gases.

IAMs often have long been criticized by those convinced they underestimate the costs of climate damages, in some cases to a degree that climate scientists consider absurd.

Perhaps the most prominent IAM is the Dynamic Integrated Climate-Economy (DICE) model, for which its creator, William Nordhaus, was awarded the 2018 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. Judging by DICE, the economically optimal carbon emissions pathway – that is, the pathway considered most cost-effective – would lead to a warming increase of more than 3°C (5.4°F) from pre-industrial temperatures by 2100 (under a 3% discount rate). IPCC has reported that reaching this level of further warming could likely result in severe consequences, including substantial species extinctions and very high risks of food supply instabilities.

In their Nature Sustainability study, the UC Davis researchers find that when natural capital is incorporated into the models, the emissions pathway that yields the best outcome for the global economy is more consistent with the dangerous risks posed by continued global warming described in the published climate science literature.

Accounting for climate change degrading of natural capital

Natural capital includes elements of nature that produce value to people either directly or indirectly. “DICE models economic production as a function of generic capital and labor,” Moore explained via email. “If instead you think natural capital plays some distinct role in economic production, and that climate change will disproportionately affect natural capital, then the economic implications are much larger than if you just roll everything together and allow damage to affect output.”

Bastien-Olvera offered an analogy to explain the incorporation of natural capital into the models: “The standard approach looks at how climate change is damaging ‘the fruit of the tree’ (market goods); we are looking at how climate change is damaging the ‘tree’ itself (natural capital).”

In an adaptation of DICE they call “GreenDICE,” the authors incorporated climate impacts on natural capital via three pathways:

The first pathway accounts for the direct influence of natural capital on market goods. Some industries like timber, agriculture, and fisheries are heavily dependent on natural capital, but all goods produced in the economy rely on these natural resources to some degree.

According to GreenDICE, this pathway alone more than doubles the model’s central estimate of the social cost of carbon in 2020 from $28 per ton in the standard DICE model to $72 per ton, and the new economically optimal pathway would have society limit global warming to 2.2°C (4°F) above pre-industrial temperatures by 2100.

The second pathway incorporates ecosystem services that don’t directly feed into market goods. Examples are the flood protection provided by a healthy mangrove forest, or the recreational benefits provided by natural places.

In the study, this second pathway nearly doubles the social cost of carbon once again, to $133 per ton in 2020, and it lowers the most cost-effective pathway to 1.8°C (3.2°F) by 2100.

Finally, the third pathway includes non-use values, which incorporate the value people place on species or natural places, regardless of any good they produce. The most difficult to quantify, this pathway could be measured, for instance, by asking people how much they would be willing to pay to save one of these species from extinction.

In GreenDICE, non-use values increase the social cost of carbon to $160 per ton of carbon dioxide in 2020 (rising to about $300 in 2050 and $670 per ton in 2100) and limit global warming to about 1.5°C (2.8°F) by 2100 in the new economically optimal emissions pathway.

(Note for economics wonks – the model runs used a 1.5% pure rate of time preference.)

Climate economics findings increasingly reinforce Paris targets

It may come as no surprise that destabilizing Earth’s climate would be a costly proposition, but key IAMs have suggested otherwise. Based on the new Nature Sustainability study, the models have been missing the substantial value of natural capital associated with healthy ecosystems that are being degraded by climate change.

Columbia University economist Noah Kaufman, not involved in the study, noted via email that as long as federal agencies use the social cost of carbon in IAMs for rulemaking cost-benefit analyses, efforts like GreenDICE are important to improving those estimates. According to Kaufman, many papers (including one he authored a decade ago) have tried to improve IAMs by following a similar recipe: “start with DICE => find an important problem => improve the methodology => produce a (usually much higher) social cost of carbon.”

For example, several other papers published in recent years, including one authored by Moore, have suggested that, because they neglect ways that climate change will slow economic growth, IAMs may also be significantly underestimating climate damage costs. Poorer countries – often located in already-hot climates near the equator, with economies relying most heavily on natural capital, and lacking resources to adapt to climate change – are the most vulnerable to its damages, despite their being the least responsible for the carbon pollution causing the climate crisis.

Another recent study in Nature Climate Change updated the climate science and economics assumptions in DICE and similarly concluded that the most cost-effective emissions pathway would limit global warming to less than 2°C (3.6°F) by 2100, without even including the value of natural capital. Asked about that paper, Bastien-Olvera noted, “In my view, the fact that these two studies get to similar policy conclusions using two very different approaches definitely indicates the urgency of cutting emissions.”

Recent economics and climate science research findings consistently support more aggressive carbon emissions efforts consistent with the Paris climate targets.

Wesleyan University economist Gary Yohe, also not involved in the study, agreed that the new Nature Sustainability study “supports growing calls for aggressive near-term mitigation.” Yohe said the paper “provides added support to the notion that climate risks to natural capital are important considerations, especially in calibrating the climate risk impacts of all sorts of regulations like CAFE standards.”

But Yohe said he believes that considering the risks to unique and threatened systems at higher temperatures makes a more persuasive case for climate policy than just attempting to assess their economic impacts. In a recent Nature Climate Change paper, Kaufman and colleagues similarly suggested that policymakers should select a net-zero emissions target informed by the best available science and economics, and then use models to set a carbon price that would achieve those goals. Their study estimated that to reach net-zero carbon pollution by 2050, the U.S. should set a carbon price of about $50 per ton in 2025, rising to $100 per ton by 2030.

However climate damages are evaluated, whether through a more complete economic accounting of adverse impacts or via risk-based assessments of physical threats to ecological and human systems, recent economics and climate science research findings consistently support more aggressive carbon emissions efforts consistent with the Paris climate targets.

Dana Nuccitelli

By

Source: We Can’t Fight Climate Change Without Valuing Nature – The Good Men Project

..

.

More Contents:

Questionable exclusion from climate summit
[…]   Surprisingly Pakistan which is among the countries worst hit by the climate change, is contributing to shape global climate change discourse as the Vice President of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and member of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, has not been invited […]
0
The Dry Corridor: Climate Change’s Impact on Hunger in Central America
sfcir.secure.force.com – Today
[…]   Carlos Fuller is the International and Regional Liaison Officer of the Caribbean Community Climate Change Centre, an intergovernmental organization established to coordinate CARICOM’s response to climate change. Mr. Fuller’s primary responsibility is to coordinate the region in the international climate change negotiation process […]
2
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards
abcnews.go.com – Today
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
0
“Crisis of Capitalism”: Roberto Lovato on How U.S. Policies Fuel Migration & Instability
[…] number of asylum seekers are arriving at the southern border, fleeing extreme poverty, violence and climate change in their home countries […] It’s just there’s different actors, different conditions — for example, like climate change […] The new animal and the new beast in the room is climate change […]
5
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards
abcnews.go.com – Today
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
3
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards GOP Democrats Arizona California Colorado
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
N/A
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards
waow.com – Today
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
0
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards – StarTribune.com
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
0
Farm Insurance Coverage in Edmonton, Alberta
[…] This province gets more than its fair share of severe weather, and with climate change being an ever-growing concern, it’s in the best interest of all Alberta farmers to expect th […]
0
GOP lawmakers take aim at Arizona renewable energy standards
wtop.com – Today
[…] forced to keep installing green technologies at a time when Arizona faces more extreme heat from climate change […]
0
WebPort Global – Blog Community
[…] Choden is a social entrepreneur and consultant possessing an ecosystem portfolio of careers in climate change and sustainability issues encompassing […]
0
REFLECT Webinar: Geothermal Energy in Turkey
[…] contributions to international conferences and is editor of the book “Groundwater and Ecosystems”, “Climate Change and its Effects on Water Resources, Issues of National and Global Security” (NATO Science Series […]
N/A
Milner Library provides access to Dr. Harsha Walia’s e-books ahead of her keynote lecture – News – Illinois State
news.illinoisstate.edu – Today
[…] Bringing together discussions of how conquest, capitalist globalization, and climate change are displacing people worldwide, she maps the lucrative connections between state violence […]
0
Ann Makosinski: Inventing your UBC experience
you.ubc.ca – Today
[…] Climate Grant, a $50,000 award given to “young entrepreneurs who are advancing viable solutions to climate change in Canada,” funded by Canadian Geographic and Shell […]
21
The climate crisis is seriously spooking economists
[…] the financial toll from the climate crisis is expected to rise dramatically: Economic damage from climate change is projected to reach $1 […] “People who spend their careers studying our economy are in widespread agreement that climate change will be expensive, potentially devastatingly so,” Peter Howard, economics director at the Institute […] The authors reached out to 2,169 economists who have published articles related to climate change in a highly-rated economic journal […]
12
Finnish vertical farming technology saves water and reduces energy consumption –
greenhouse.news – Today
[…] Environmental issues and climate change set various challenges on farming […]
1
Democrats’ $8.3B budget primed for passage after party-line House vote
bangordailynews.com – Today
[…] Sophia Warren, I-Scarborough, to direct the Maine Climate Council to seek funding for climate change initiatives was killed in the House […]
1
The Answer To Anti-Asian Racism Is Not More Policing
popularresistance.org – Today
[…] Kayla Hui (she/her) is a freelance journalist covering health, policy, social justice, and climate change […]
0
Rexel : AMENDMENT TO THE 2020 UNIVERSAL REGISTRATION DOCUMENT MADE AVAILABLE | MarketScreener
[…] Rexel is rated A- in the 2020 CDP Climate Change assessment and ranked in the 2020 CDP Supplier Engagement Leaderboard […]
0
US, EU financial regulators meet to discuss stablecoins and CBDCs ⋆
[…] The US officials also touched on climate change and how it constitutes potentially an economic risk […]
0
Covering Climate Now: Katrina vanden Heuvel, The Nation – Morningside Area Alliance
morningside-alliance.org – Today
[…] Heuvel, The Nation WATCH LATER SUBSCRIBE News media can no longer be complacent when it comes to climate change […]
0
Understanding the Health Harms of Climate Change: A Six Americas Analysis
mailchi.mp – Today
Dear Friends, Over the past six years, Americans have become increasingly aware that climate change threatens human health in multiple ways […] Six Americas, six segments of the public that differ in their understanding of and concern about climate change.    We find that awareness of climate change health harms has increased not only among the two audience segments that are most worried abou […] Director, Yale Program on Climate Change Communication Yale School of the Environment (203) 432-4865 Twitter: @ecotone2 environment […]
0
“Dairy Feed in Focus” program aims to drive economic and environmental benefits for farmers
[…] “Dairy Feed in Focus” is another way of contributing to global food production, while addressing climate change, water security and biodiversity […]
0
50 Times Architects Really Outdid Themselves And People Celebrated Their Works Online
[…] responsible and more resource-efficient, which are both vital to reducing the effects of climate change […]
N/A
COVID: Angela Merkel vows to take tough action | Germany| News and in-depth reporting from Berlin and beyond | DW | 29.03.2021
[…] They have benefited from new urgency to address climate change and the electorate’s disenchantment with the current “grand coalition” of CDU/CSU and th […]
0
MTM- So Much More Than Just a Lift | Company Report | Technology
[…] cares about community impact, and we feel very strongly about diversity, equity, inclusion, and climate change […]
1
A Unified Research Data Infrastructure for Catalysis Research – Challenges and Concepts – Wulf – – ChemCatChem – Wiley Online Library
chemistry-europe.onlinelibrary.wiley.com – Today
[…] 1 Introduction Catalysis is a key technology field for solving the challenges related to climate change and a sustainable supply of energy and materials […]
N/A
PM call with President Joko Widodo of Indonesia: 30 March 2021
[…] They discussed the opportunities for collaboration to tackle climate change and protect nature, and the Prime Minister highlighted the importance of setting ambitious 203 […]
0
What Your Finance Chief Should Learn From Auto Industry CFOs
chiefexecutive.net – Today
[…] In one clear example, the Biden administration’s renewed focus on climate change is pushing the industry hard in the direction of environmental sustainability […]
N/A
Purolator deploys fully electric delivery vehicles in Vancouver; Motiv Power Systems
ecotopical.com – Today
[…] of Super-Polluting Methane Gas, With or Without the Republicans InsideClimate News 96 How Will Climate Change Affect Hailstorms? ENN 91 Baker Hughes acquires exclusive license from SRI International for mixe […]
1
Austin looks to blockchain to help the homeless – Cities Today – CRYPTO CRYPTO NEWS
cryptocryptonews.com – Today
[…] power for up to 5,000 homes, the scheme aims to address historic environmental justice concerns, climate change, and economic development in underserved communities […]
0
Google Maps to start directing drivers to ‘eco-friendly’ routes – Software
[…] this year in the US and eventually reach other countries as part of its commitment to help combat climate change through its services […]
2
ESG Litigation in Europe
[…] Equally, in relation to environmental claims, concerns about climate change have dramatically altered the profile of environmental litigation away from claims seeking t […] [xi] There has also been a slew of climate change litigation including directly against companies. According to LSE’s 2020 study of climate change lawsuit trends, litigation against major oil and gas companies has increased significantly sinc […]
0
Remote monitoring could boost the use of nature-based solutions to safeguard against natural hazards | EurekAlert! Science News
[…] protect communities from devastating natural hazards such as floods, storms and landslides, say climate change experts from the University of Surrey […] manage their growing population and address the planet’s ongoing struggle against urbanisation and climate change […] of Surrey, said: “Unfortunately we do expect a significant uptick in natural hazards, thanks to climate change […]
0
Google Maps to start directing drivers to ‘eco-friendly’ routes in U.S. | Toronto Sun
torontosun.com – Today
[…] and eventually reach other countries as part of its commitment to help combat climate change through its services […]
N/A
Factors that may predict next pandemic
[…]   Modelling from the Sydney School of Veterinary Science suggests pressure on ecosystems, climate change and economic development are key factors associated with the diversification of pathogen […]   These factors combined confirm human development – including human-influenced climate change – not only damages our environment but is responsible for the emergence of infectious diseases […] suggests sustainable development is not only critical to maintaining ecosystems and slowing climate change; it can inform disease control, mitigation, or prevention,” Professor Ward said […]
N/A
Google Maps to start directing drivers to ‘eco-friendly’ routes
[…] and eventually reach other countries as part of its commitment to help combat climate change through its services […]
2
Want to create 5 million green jobs? Invest in public transport in cities | Business
[…] Cities are key to combating climate change because they generate three-quarters of carbon emissions, earlier studies have found, with urgen […]
0
Grain School returns to UCCS in April event –
communique.uccs.edu – Today
[…] and their relationship to health, nutrition, dietary fiber, and the microbiome, environment and climate change issues related to agriculture, and topics of biodiversity, grain’s role in sustainable farmin […]
0
UMD study suggests supporting Indonesian women in conservation supports biodiversity –
bioengineer.org – Today
[…] “Climate change, habitat loss and encroachment, an increasing human population putting stress on natura […]
0
Government Innovation
annualreport.bloomberg.org – Today
[…] cities” with funding and guidance to develop and test local responses to challenges around climate change, health, and other critical issues […]
8
in ClimateChangeMitigation.eu’s newsletter
climatestorylines.eu – Today
[…] eu Interested in climate change mitigation? Subscribe to the ClimateChangeMitigation […]
N/A
Can sustainability save capitalism? | Greenbiz
[…] wiping out poverty, protecting human rights, ensuring clean water and sanitation and mitigating climate change are no longer seen as do-good fantasies […] but its roots emanate from the publication of Laudato si’, Pope Francis’ 2015 encyclical on climate change […]
2
Valuing water:  An elusive ‘blue gold’ to billions   –
mb.com.ph – Today
[…]   Water scarcity, flooding and climate change can push up costs and disrupt supply chains […]
0

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: